Tuesday, May 30, 2023 at 12:37 PM
Confessions: Sat. morning 9:30am ~ Sat vigil Mass: 4:00pm ~ Sunday morning Mass: 8:00 and 9:30 in English and 11:00 in Spanish. Summer office hours: 9:30am ~ 2pm Monday thru Friday

A warning about ‘synodality’ in the Church from half a century ago


People fretting over the pros and cons of synodality should seek enlightenment in the story of “shared responsibility” half a century ago. History doesn’t literally repeat itself, but what happened then suggests why we need to move ahead carefully now while avoiding new mistakes.

Shared responsibility — the Synodality Lite of the 1970s, you might call it — was all the rage in the heady days right after the Second Vatican Council. Meetings were held and documents published promoting the idea, and preliminary steps were taken by setting up pastoral councils of clergy, religious and laity in dioceses throughout the country.

As planners saw it, the capstone of this burgeoning superstructure would be a National Pastoral Council where bishops, priests, religious and laypeople could hammer out policy for the Church’s socio-political program at the national level.

Call To Action

According to the plan, this national body would be a fusion of the U.S. Catholic Conference (created after Vatican II along with the National Conference of Catholic Bishops) with the National Advisory Council recently created to counsel the bishops.

But the Vatican stepped in and, in a letter to bishops, essentially said: No, not now. The reason seemed to be that a National Pastoral Council in the Netherlands was held to blame for the dismaying implosion of Dutch Catholicism then taking place.

Rather than go away quietly, however, shared responsibility made a noisy comeback via a boondoggle with the provocative name Call To Action. Who were called and to what action were left unstated. Promoted as the crown jewel of the American bishops’ contribution to the U.S. bicentennial, and preceded by “hearings” staged in several parts of the country to whip up interest, Call To Action brought together 1,340 delegates in Detroit for three days in October 1976.

And who, you may ask, were those delegates? Conservative writer Russell Kirk, there as a journalist, called them “church mice.” Most were chosen by their bishops and, as later investigation determined, half were on the Church’s payroll.

Among the 218 recommendations produced by this highly unrepresentative body were proposals for ordaining women and married men, taking an open attitude toward homosexuality, approving contraception and giving Communion to divorced and remarried Catholics whose first marriages hadn’t been annulled.

The conference of bishops promised to study the proposals. Not surprisingly, that was the end of it.

Old things new again

The differences between then and now are obviously very real. Then it was the Vatican that nixed national pastoral councils; now it’s Pope Francis who is the moving force behind synodality. But the Call To Action of 1976 unquestionably has a family resemblance to the recent “synodal path” in Germany, with its much-discussed set of proposals that, while bearing the imprint of 2023, nevertheless sound remarkably like the Call To Action laundry list of 1976. Is this perhaps a case of what Yogi Berra memorably called “Déjà vu all over again”?

The Vatican shelved Synodality Lite at the national level half a century ago. But now, the Holy Father wants universal synodality, and the Synod of Bishops that meets this October (and again, for reasons not clear, in October next year) will undoubtedly give it to him.

Moreover, just as in 1976, now there really is a case for greatly expanding the participation of loyal, competent laypeople in setting directions for the Church. But the experience with Call To Action is a disturbing reminder that there also are excellent reasons to hope the big winner doesn’t turn out instead to be today’s woke Catholicism.

This article comes to you from Our Sunday Visitor courtesy of your parish or diocese.


Catholic News & Perspective

Provides information on the Church, the nation and the world from OSV, America's most popular and trusted national Catholic news source


A warning about ‘synodality’ in the Church from half a century ago

Wednesday, June 7, 2023
by Russell Shaw People fretting over the pros and cons of synodality should seek enlightenment in the story of “shared... Read More

Undeterred by fear, China’s ‘Little Li’ offers an important lesson in religious liberty

Monday, June 5, 2023
by Sofia Cornicelli The following essay was selected as the winner of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops’ religious liberty... Read More

Meditating upon what God is

Friday, June 2, 2023
By:  Father Joshua J. Whitfield Trinity Sunday is different. From Advent to Pentecost, the Church invites us to celebrate what God... Read More

Encounter Jesus to be revived and changed

Wednesday, May 31, 2023
By:  Bishop Andrew H. Cozzens I am always amazed that on the road to Emmaus, as the two disciples journeyed from Jerusalem, they did not... Read More

What Catholics should know ahead of the Synod of Bishops

Monday, May 29, 2023
By: Msgr. Owen F. Campion Several months will pass before October comes, but in October, many Catholics will be led, whether they like it or... Read More

The symbolic meaning of fire and water

Friday, May 26, 2023
By: Catherine Cavadini Fire and water: These are two scriptural symbols of the Holy Spirit. We hear about them in the readings for Pentecost.... Read More

The commencement gift I never expected

Wednesday, May 24, 2023
By: Kathryn Jean Lopez I didn’t go to my college commencement ceremony. I graduated in three years and had my diploma delivered by... Read More

Archbishop Coakley’s letter on gender dysphoria is valuable, full of love

Monday, May 22, 2023
By: Msgr. Owen F. Campion Archbishop Paul S. Coakley of Oklahoma City has written an official pastoral letter for the people of his... Read More

The hope of the Ascension

Friday, May 19, 2023
By: Father Joshua J. Whitfield “I yearn for resurrection’s joy and yet / Each surge to heaven seems to sink again.”... Read More

Missouri lawmakers ban gender reassignment surgery, treatments for minors

Wednesday, May 17, 2023
By: Kate Scanlon (OSV News) — Missouri lawmakers passed a bill May 10 banning certain types of medical or surgical gender reassignment... Read More

Online Giving

Online Giving

Secure and Convenient Donate now!